Salary Negotiation Success Odds: How the Numbers Are Calculated

Contents
The "negotiation success probability" and "after-tax monthly take-home increase" shown by the Salary Negotiation Simulator aren't gut feelings — they come from fixed calculation rules. If you're a working professional who can't tell how much of a raise to ask for, knowing these rules lets you check by hand why the screen shows the percentage it does. This post isn't about negotiation strategy. It breaks down the calculation rules themselves, straight from the source.
Summary ① Negotiation success probability starts with the default value for your performance rating (S through C), adds or subtracts based on which raise-request bracket you fall into, adds your tenure up to a maximum of 10 percentage points, then clamps the result between 5% and 95%. ② A requested raise of 5% or less isn't penalized at all — it actually gets a +10 percentage point bonus. Above 20%, the penalty is the steepest at -45 percentage points. ③ The after-tax monthly take-home increase is an approximation that assumes a fixed 16% deduction rate. It does not reflect your personal social insurance, tax rate, or dependent deductions.
Why these numbers get confusing
There's a situation most people run into while setting a target raise before a salary negotiation. You've received an offer from another company or you're heading into your regular review meeting, and you've picked the salary you want. But it's hard to judge on your own whether that percentage is realistic given your performance rating and tenure.
Looking at a single raise percentage, it's easy to just eyeball it and think, "that should be about right." But a 15% raise request looks completely different for an S-rated employee with 10 years of tenure versus a C-rated employee in year one. The calculator's job is to boil that difference down into a single probability number.
How to calculate it yourself without the tool
Both numbers the calculator shows come out of fixed rules. You can work them out by hand in the order below, without opening the calculator.
Step 1 — Find the requested raise percentage. Calculate (target salary − current salary) ÷ current salary × 100. If your current salary is 40 million won and your target is 44.8 million won, then (44.8 million − 40 million) ÷ 40 million × 100 = a 12% requested raise.
Step 2 — Start from the base probability for your performance rating.
| Rating | Base probability |
|---|---|
| S | 85% |
| A | 70% |
| B | 50% |
| C | 15% |
Step 3 — Adjust based on the requested raise bracket.
| Requested raise bracket | Adjustment |
|---|---|
| 5% or less | +10 percentage points |
| 5–10% | -5 percentage points |
| 10–15% | -15 percentage points |
| 15–20% | -30 percentage points |
| Over 20% | -45 percentage points |
12% falls in the "10–15%" bracket, so -15 percentage points applies.
Step 4 — Add your tenure. Add tenure × 1 percentage point, capped at a maximum of 10 percentage points. Whether you're in year 11 or year 20, this bonus never exceeds 10 percentage points. In year 6, it's +6 percentage points.
Step 5 — Clamp to the 5–95% range. If the total from steps 1–4 is below 5%, set it to 5%. If it's above 95%, set it to 95%.
Carrying the earlier example through: start with the A-rating base of 70, subtract 15 for the 12% bracket penalty, and add 6 for year 6. That's 61. It's inside the 5–95% range, so 61% is your final success probability.
You can work out the after-tax monthly take-home increase the same way by hand. The formula is salary ÷ 12 × 0.84. The 0.84 assumes a 16% combined deduction rate for social insurance and income tax. Apply the formula to your current salary and your target salary separately, then take the difference.
For a current salary of 40 million won: 40 million ÷ 12 × 0.84 = about 2.8 million won. For a target salary of 44.8 million won: 44.8 million ÷ 12 × 0.84 = about 3.136 million won. The difference between the two, about 336,000 won, is your expected monthly take-home increase.
Check it with our free tool.
Just enter your current salary, target salary, performance rating, and years of tenure, and it instantly calculates your negotiation success odds and the increase in your after-tax monthly take-home pay.

Points that trip people up
A lower raise percentage isn't automatically better. The 5%-or-less bracket isn't a penalty — it's actually a +10 percentage point bonus. On the flip side, the moment you cross 5% and land in the 5–10% bracket, it flips to -5 percentage points. 4% and 6% are only 2 percentage points apart, but in the formula they're 15 percentage points apart: a +10 bonus versus a -5 penalty.
There's also a structural reason the probability drops sharply above 20%. The bracket penalties themselves are designed to grow as the raise goes up: -5, -15, -30, and -45 percentage points. So in the over-20% bracket, even an S rating (85%, the highest base) ends up with a much lower final probability.
Longer tenure doesn't keep helping forever either. The tenure bonus is tenure × 1 percentage point, but it's capped at 10 percentage points. Year 10 and year 20 both get exactly +10 percentage points here.
The take-home increase also won't show up on your bank statement exactly as calculated. The 16% deduction rate is a simplified assumption that doesn't reflect your personal social insurance rates, income tax brackets, or dependent deductions. Your actual deduction rate varies with your income bracket, number of dependents, and the national pension and health insurance rates.
| Item | How this calculator computes it | Why it may differ from reality |
|---|---|---|
| Negotiation success probability | Rating base + raise bracket adjustment + tenure bonus (max 10 percentage points), clamped to 5–95% | Variables outside the rules, such as company budget and negotiation style, are not reflected |
| Take-home increase | Difference between (salary ÷ 12 × 0.84) for current and target salary | The 16% deduction rate is a fixed assumption; personal social insurance, tax rates, and dependent deductions are not reflected |
The bottom line
- Negotiation success probability is a rule-based estimate: start from the base value for your performance rating (S through C), adjust by requested raise bracket, add tenure up to 10 percentage points, then clamp between 5% and 95%.
- A requested raise of 5% or less gets a +10 percentage point bonus rather than a penalty, while anything above 20% takes the largest penalty at -45 percentage points.
- The tenure bonus is tenure × 1 percentage point, but it never exceeds 10 percentage points, so past year 10 this item stops growing.
- The after-tax monthly take-home increase is an approximation assuming a fixed 16% deduction rate, and it does not reflect your personal social insurance, tax rates, or dependent deductions.
- These two numbers don't guarantee any negotiation outcome. They're reference estimates that come out of plugging your inputs into the rules.
Just enter your current salary, target salary, performance rating, and years of tenure, and it instantly calculates your negotiation success odds and the increase in your after-tax monthly take-home pay.
Frequently asked questions
What percentage counts as safe for a negotiation success probability?
This calculator doesn't label any percentage as "safe" or "risky." The probability is just the result of plugging three inputs — performance rating, requested raise, and tenure — into fixed rules. Whether a negotiation actually succeeds also depends on factors the formula doesn't include, like company budget and negotiation style.
Is a lower raise percentage always better?
No. The +10 percentage point bonus applies only in the 5%-or-less bracket, and the moment you go above 5% it flips to -5 percentage points. After that, the penalties keep growing: -15 percentage points at 10–15%, -30 at 15–20%, and -45 above 20%. So "lower is better" isn't the right description — "the penalty grows each time you cross a bracket boundary" is.
Could the take-home increase differ from my actual pay stub?
Yes, it could. This calculator fixes the deduction rate at 16% and computes (salary ÷ 12 × 0.84), which is a simple approximation. It doesn't reflect your personal conditions — actual social insurance rates, income tax brackets, dependent deductions — so it may differ from the increase on your real pay stub.
Does entering more tenure keep helping?
Only up to 10 percentage points. The tenure bonus is calculated as tenure × 1 percentage point but capped at 10 percentage points, so from year 10 onward, entering more tenure doesn't increase this item.
This article was adapted from our Korean original. Read the Korean original