Why PM2.5 "Bad" Levels Differ by App: Korea vs. WHO vs. US AQI

PublishedToolKorea Real-Time Air Quality (PM10 & PM2.5)

Contents
  1. The Korean standards, exactly
  2. Why U.S. apps make air quality look worse: and the twist
  3. Why the WHO guidelines are so low
  4. Why Korean apps disagree with each other, too
  5. Why "Bad" Air Doesn't Come With an Advisory
  6. How to Check It Yourself, No Tool Needed
  7. How Do You Decide on a Mask?
  8. The Short Version
  9. Frequently Asked Questions

If you open three air quality apps and get three different grades, the apps aren't broken. They're putting the same number into different tables. In Korea's forecast grades, "Bad" starts at fine particulate matter (PM2.5) of 36 ㎍/㎥. The WHO 24-hour recommendation is 15 ㎍/㎥. The U.S. AQI moves into Moderate at 9.1.

Summary In Korea, PM2.5 of 36 and up is "Bad." The WHO 24-hour recommendation is 15. The U.S. AQI turns Moderate at 9.1. PM10 is different, though: Korea is stricter than the U.S. Neither side is looser across the board. Grade labels change with the table. What you can trust is the number from the monitoring station.

The Korean standards, exactly

Korea has two tables that deal with particulate matter numbers. One is the legal standard. The other is the forecast grade you see in apps. People often mix them up and quote them interchangeably, but they serve different purposes.

The legal standard is in 환경정책기본법 시행령 [별표 1] 환경기준. It isn't a table for deciding "Should I wear a mask today?" It's a target for how clean the country must keep its air.

ItemAnnual average24-hour average
Particulate matter (PM-10)50 ㎍/㎥ or less100 ㎍/㎥ or less
Fine particulate matter (PM-2.5)15 ㎍/㎥ or less35 ㎍/㎥ or less

The original text of the annex adds one caveat. The 24-hour average must not exceed the standard at the 99th percentile. In other words, a few days over the limit in a year don't automatically count as exceeding the standard.

An environmental standard isn't a regulatory limit that governs individuals or businesses. It's a target the country works toward and tries to maintain. So "35 and over is a legal violation" doesn't hold up. It isn't a standard you can violate.

The Good/Moderate/Bad/Very Bad labels you see in apps come from a separate forecast grade table.

GradePM-10PM-2.5
Good0~300~15
Moderate31~8016~35
Bad81~15036~75
Very Bad151 and up76 and up

It's no coincidence that the upper end of PM2.5 "Moderate" is 35, the same number as the legal 24-hour standard of 35. The moment you cross the legal standard is where "Bad" begins.

For reference, this PM2.5 standard was tightened on March 27, 2018. The annual limit went from 25 to 15, and the 24-hour limit from 50 to 35. If the air feels the same but "Bad" days seem to have increased since some point, that's not your memory playing tricks. The table changed.

Why U.S. apps make air quality look worse: and the twist

Many apps from outside Korea use the U.S. EPA's AQI ranges. For PM2.5 on a 24-hour basis, Good is 0.0~9.0, Moderate is 9.1~35.4, Unhealthy for Sensitive Groups is 35.5~55.4, and Unhealthy starts at 55.5. A revision that took effect on May 6, 2024 lowered the top of the Good range from 12.0 to 9.0.

Put the same numbers into both tables and you get this.

Measured valueKorean forecast gradeU.S. AQI
PM2.5 12GoodModerate
PM2.5 30ModerateModerate
PM2.5 60BadUnhealthy
PM10 40ModerateGood
PM10 100BadModerate

This is where the conventional wisdom falls apart. Korea is lenient on PM2.5, but PM10 is where Korea is stricter. The U.S. AQI is Good up to PM10 54 and Moderate up to 154. Unhealthy for Sensitive Groups starts at 155. Korea is Moderate from 31 and Bad from 81. On a day with PM10 100, a Korean app says "Bad" and a U.S.-style app says "Moderate." The direction flips.

So the one-line summary "Korea's standards are soft" is only half right. The answer depends on the pollutant. Both tables above come from published primary sources, so if you're curious, you can check the math yourself.

Why the WHO guidelines are so low

The WHO's 2021 guidelines (AQG) set PM2.5 at 5 for the annual average and 15 for 24 hours. On an annual basis, that's one-third of Korea's level. That's where the line "Korea ignores the WHO" comes from. But when you open the WHO document, you find that it serves a different purpose.

WHO describes its own guidelines this way: “Whereas guidelines are not legally binding recommendations, they can be used as an evidence-informed reference tool to help decision-makers in setting legally binding standards and goals for air quality management at international, national and local level.” In other words, it's an evidence base offered as a reference when countries create legally binding standards. Korea's standard is law. The WHO recommendation is material for making law. The roles are different.

More important, the WHO didn't issue only a final recommendation. It also designed interim targets, IT1 through IT4. They're steps for countries that can't reach 5 ㎍/㎥ right now. Put Korea's standards on those steps and the position becomes clear.

ItemKorean standardWhere it sits in the WHO scale
PM2.5 annual 15Legal standardMatches IT3 (15)
PM2.5 24-hour 35Legal standardBetween IT4 (25) and IT3 (37.5)
PM10 annual 50Legal standardMatches IT2 (50)
PM10 24-hour 100Legal standardMatches IT2 (100)

Korea didn't ignore the WHO. It stands partway up the staircase the WHO built. There's still a gap to the final recommendation (PM2.5 annual 5), and that's true. But "Korea's standards are wrong" and "Korea's standards sit at a more relaxed step than the WHO's final recommendation" are completely different statements.

The WHO's 24-hour values also have a footnote: "99th percentile (3~4 days over the limit per year allowed)." That's the same structure as the 99th-percentile caveat in Korea's Annex 1.

Why Korean apps disagree with each other, too

From here on, standards alone can't explain it. Two Korean apps using the same Korean standards can show different grades for the same area. The reason is that the value called a "grade" was never just one thing.

The AirKorea real-time measurement API doesn't give you only one kind of grade. Even for PM10 alone, the grade based on the 24-hour standard and the grade based on the most recent one-hour value come in separate fields. The range table may be identical, but a 24-hour average and the last hour's value are naturally different numbers. Which field an app reads is enough to split the labels.

And there's one more thing. Our free tool pulls khaiGrade from this API, the comprehensive air quality index grade. The comprehensive air quality index doesn't look at particulate matter alone. It reflects several air pollutants together (score ranges: Good 0~50 / Moderate 51~100 / Bad 101~250 / Very Bad 251~500). So the grade badge on our screen and the badge in another app that shows only a "PM2.5 grade" can differ at the same moment. Neither one is wrong. They're looking at different values.

That leads to the conclusion. A grade label is the result of which table and which field were chosen. The only thing that doesn't shift is the measured number.

Why "Bad" Air Doesn't Come With an Advisory

Forecast grades and advisories/warnings are separate systems. Mix them up and it gets confusing.

  • Forecast: today's, tomorrow's, and the day after's daily average prediction, shown in 4 levels
  • Real-time measurement: the value a station is reporting right now
  • Advisory/warning: issued when actual concentrations stay above a threshold for 2 hours or more

Advisories and warnings have their own legal basis: Article 8 of the Clean Air Conservation Act, Article 2 of the Enforcement Decree of the same Act, and Article 14 and Annex 7 of the Enforcement Rule.

CategoryIssuedLifted
PM-10 advisory150㎍/㎥ or higher sustained for 2 hours or morebelow 100
PM-10 warning300㎍/㎥ or higher sustained for 2 hours or moreswitches to advisory when below 150
PM-2.5 advisory75㎍/㎥ or higher sustained for 2 hours or morebelow 35
PM-2.5 warning150㎍/㎥ or higher sustained for 2 hours or moreswitches to advisory when below 75

A PM2.5 "Bad" grade starts at 36, but an advisory starts at 75 — and even then it has to last 2 hours or more. So getting no text message on a "Bad" day is normal. The two systems answer different questions. A forecast grade asks, "What will tomorrow be like?" An advisory asks, "Is an unusually high level continuing right now?"

How to Check It Yourself, No Tool Needed

Anyone can view the government's raw data for free.

  1. Go to AirKorea (airkorea.or.kr)
  2. Under real-time air information, pick a province
  3. In the station list, find the station closest to your neighborhood and check its PM10 and PM2.5 values (㎍/㎥)
  4. Plug those numbers straight into the forecast grade table above

The number on screen is the average for the previous hour. So the grade you get from the table is a "1-hour grade," and it's normal for it to differ from an app showing a 24-hour grade. Both use the same table — they're just feeding it different numbers.

Look at the number instead of the grade badge and put it into the table yourself. That's the key. One more thing: some stations show -. That means the equipment is being serviced. Some apps fill in a nearby station's value in that case, which means you're looking at air from a different spot entirely.

If opening the site, picking a province, and hunting down your station every time is a hassle, we built a tool that shows the same AirKorea real-time data, station by station, with the numbers left as they are.

Korea Real-Time Air Quality (PM10 & PM2.5)

See the raw AirKorea readings by monitoring station — check the original numbers, not the grade labels

Plug the PM10 and PM2.5 numbers from the screen into the table above, and you can see for yourself why the grade badge came out the way it did.

How Do You Decide on a Mask?

I'll be straight with you. We could not confirm a grade-by-grade mask recommendation ("from PM2.5 X, wear KF Y") in any primary government source. Most of what search turns up is news coverage, and the MFDS material mixes in infectious-disease response context. We're not going to invent unverified numbers for you here.

Here's what we can confirm instead. The MFDS officially explains the KF grades themselves — what KF80, KF94 and so on mean. Look for the "KF mark" guidance on mfds.go.kr. And you can judge where today's air sits using the table above. PM2.5 40 is the low end of the "Bad" band, and 75 is the advisory threshold. Within the same "Bad" band, 37 and 74 are exactly double each other. Look only at the label and that difference disappears entirely.

The Short Version

  • Korea's "Bad" forecast grade starts at PM2.5 36 and PM10 81.
  • The legal standard (Annex 1) is PM2.5 35 for 24 hours / 15 annually, with a 99th percentile caveat. It's a national target, not a regulation that governs individuals.
  • The U.S. AQI is stricter for PM2.5, and Korea is stricter for PM10.
  • WHO recommendations are evidence, not law, and Korea's standards sit on the WHO interim targets IT2–IT3 line.
  • Korean apps disagree with each other because there are several grade fields (24-hour/1-hour, integrated index/individual pollutant).
  • What never wobbles is the station number. Look at the number, not the label.
Korea Real-Time Air Quality (PM10 & PM2.5)

See the raw AirKorea readings by monitoring station — check the original numbers, not the grade labels

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a PM2.5 reading of 35 "Bad" or "Moderate"?

By Korea's forecast grade, it's Moderate. "Moderate" is 16–35, and "Bad" starts at 36. So 35 is the last slot of Moderate. That said, 35 is also the ceiling of the legal 24-hour standard (35㎍/㎥ or less). On the U.S. AQI, that same 35 lands near the very top of Moderate (9.1–35.4), and against the WHO 24-hour recommendation (15) it's more than double. It's a textbook case of one number reading differently depending on the table.

Three apps give three different grades. Which one is right?

All three can be right. It's usually one of three reasons. First, the reference tables differ (Korea forecast grade / U.S. AQI / WHO recommendation). Second, even with the same Korean standard, the field being read differs — a 24-hour grade versus a 1-hour grade, or a particulate-only grade versus an integrated air quality index grade, will split the label. Third, the stations differ. There's one way to check: compare the PM10 and PM2.5 numbers all three apps show. If the numbers match and only the grades differ, it's the table or the field. If the numbers differ, it's the station or the timestamp.

Is it true Korea's standards are looser than WHO's?

Compared with WHO's final guidelines (AQG), yes. Korea's annual PM2.5 standard is 15; the WHO recommendation is 5. But WHO didn't issue only a final guideline — it also designed interim targets IT1–IT4, and Korea's annual PM2.5 of 15 matches IT3, while PM10 annual 50 and 24-hour 100 each match IT2. WHO states that its guidelines are not legally binding and are the evidence base countries use when setting their own legal standards. The two documents play different roles, so deciding which one is wrong isn't really the question.

It's "Bad" but I'm not getting an emergency alert. Why?

Because forecast grades and advisories are separate systems. A PM2.5 advisory is issued when levels of 75㎍/㎥ or higher persist for 2 hours or more (Clean Air Conservation Act Enforcement Rule Article 14 and Annex 7). "Bad" starts at 36, so most of the Bad range falls far short of the advisory threshold. No text message doesn't mean the air is good — it means the advisory system is aimed at much higher concentrations.

This article was adapted from our Korean original. Read the Korean original

Related articles

  1. Link Preview Not Showing? Check og Tags and Clear the CacheLink preview blank or showing an old thumbnail? It's missing og tags or cached results. How to check the source and reset the cache.
  2. Keyword Density Explained: The Real Formula and Its LimitsLearn how keyword density is calculated, why the 1–2% rule isn't a real ranking factor, and how to use it to spot awkward repetition.
  3. Is It Better to Draw First or Last? Drawing Odds ExplainedSee why your draw order doesn't change your odds, and how to work out live odds from the cards already flipped. Simple permutation math, counted by hand.
  4. Name Compatibility Hash Test: The Formula Behind the ScoreSee how two names turn into a 40–100 compatibility score with a 31 polynomial hash, Unicode handling, and deterministic results you can repeat.
  5. Lucky Color & Lucky Item Matching: Formula and Birthday GuideSee how a birthday or zodiac sign and today's date become a daily lucky color, item, number, and direction, with the formula and JavaScript code.
  6. MBTI Compatibility Chart: How 16x16 Matrix Grades Are CalculatedSee how the MBTI compatibility chart's 16x16 matrix assigns grades. We explain the scoring order, the 16 ideal pairs, and every other rule.

Related tools